About Me

Find out more about me here.
Showing posts with label medicine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label medicine. Show all posts

15 April 2017

I Can See Your Bourgeois Showing, Healthcare Edition

To the research:



Interesting! I worry, though, that the wrong conclusion is being drawn here. Healthcare workers are human. Of course they perform better when they know they are being observed. (Ahem, Hawthorne Effect!) To say that workers aren't working hard enough and should be doing more--in any field, even one where people could be bleeding out on a table--is asking too much of those workers. My spouse, who is an RN who has worked in both hospital and office settings, pointed out to me that what really changes during these periods of oversight is that administrators intervene uncharacteristically, prepping healthcare workers in important ways. To reduce this to "doctors and nurses should be working harder/better" is a problematic framing. To put it into Spinal Tap-ese (Is there a more appropriately named band for this?), turning things up to 11 for a few days is doable--and, now we know, predictable; turning things up to 11 permanently will cause the amps to overheat. We ask a lot of our healthcare workers, especially nurses and techs. Asking more of them is unjust and, ironically, could make health outcomes even worse.

Let me propose two alternative conclusions from this research. First, don't announce your oversight. If the knowledge of being observed changes behavior, don't make people aware that they're being observed. Second, perhaps it is administrators who should be prodded by these findings. Why aren't the administrators doing the things they do during these observation periods all the time? To focus on employees instead of on systems or managers reeks of capitalistic exploitation.

22 September 2015

Hating the Game instead of Just the Player

Blaming an individual for doing capitalism when we collectively have continued to allow something as essential as healthcare to remain a part of a capitalist system is like blaming the linebacker for tackling our quarterback when the rules of football not only encourage him to do so but essentially require it. Let's find a way to redirect our individual-level hatred of Martin Shkreli into action that changes things at the structural level.

14 April 2012

SOC 201: Bedside Manner?

Ugh. This article on changes to pre-med education is making me angry. Let's walk through some choice points:
In addition to the hard-science and math questions that have for decades defined this rite of passage into the medical profession, nearly half of the new MCAT will focus on squishier topics in two new sections: one covering social and behavioral sciences and another on critical analysis and reading that will require students to analyze passages covering areas like ethics and cross-cultural studies. [emphasis added]
So, the social and behavioral sciences are "squishy?"
In surveys, "the public had great confidence in doctors' knowledge but much less in their bedside manner," said Darrell G. Kirch, president of the association, in announcing the change. "The goal is to improve the medical admissions process to find the people who you and I would want as our doctors. Being a good doctor isn't just about understanding science, it's about understanding people." [emphasis added]
So, the social and behavioral sciences are not science?

Yes, absolutely, let's bring the social sciences--and particularly sociology--into the training of our physicians. The way that this is being framed, however, misses the point of doing so. Health and disease are radically social. Race gives us one example of this. Blacks in the U.S. have poor health outcomes compared to whites. For example, blacks are far more likely to suffer from hypertension, even after we take things like diet, income, occupation, eduction, and genetic predisposition into consideration. (See Unnatural Causes: Is Inequality Making Us Sick? for an excellent explanation of the social factors in our physical well-being.) Good bedside manner is important, but sociology doesn't teach about this. Sociology makes students aware of the social, but that is no guarantee of sociability. As I've written before, "...[I]ronically, sociology is about the most misanthropic discipline there is. We are the Debby Downers of academia." I'm confident, though, that the inclusion of social science into the medical curriculum will have beneficial outcomes regardless of the misunderstandings of those who implement the changes. The next generation of physicians will have a better understanding of the social causes and consequences of health and disease, and this will be good for all of us.

18 October 2011

Pulling Back the Curtain on Dr. Oz

Strike two for Oprah. Turns out that Dr. Oz is right up there with Dr. Phil. First, Dr. Oz made an inaccurate claim that apple juice contains dangerous levels of arsenic and refused to back down. Now, Dr. Oz is perpetuating a discredited theory about the genetic basis for race and is refusing to back down. Regarding both issues, he claims to have "done his homework." Stop listening to Dr. Oz! And, for that matter, can we all agree that we should be a lot more critical of Oprah, too?